SPANISH
Robert Capa´s grave at Amawalk Cemetery (New York)
Today is the Centenary of Robert Capa (born in Budapest on October 22, 1913), one of the most important war photographers ever, a genuine representative of war photojournalism who made a lot of extraordinary pictures in five different wars (Spanish Civil War, Second Sino-Japanese War, Second World War in Europe, Arab-Israeli War of 1948 and First Indochina War), founder of Magnum Agency and a man whose constant defense of his workmates through the concept of the preservation of original negatives and their ownership by the photographers getting the pictures was to revolutionize the modern photojournalism.
Today is the Centenary of Robert Capa (born in Budapest on October 22, 1913), one of the most important war photographers ever, a genuine representative of war photojournalism who made a lot of extraordinary pictures in five different wars (Spanish Civil War, Second Sino-Japanese War, Second World War in Europe, Arab-Israeli War of 1948 and First Indochina War), founder of Magnum Agency and a man whose constant defense of his workmates through the concept of the preservation of original negatives and their ownership by the photographers getting the pictures was to revolutionize the modern photojournalism.
But Robert Capa
never considered himself to be the best war photographer in the world.
Such designation
was bestowed upon him by Stefan Lorant, owner and picture editor of Picture
Post, after the publication of his superb photographs of the Battle of Segre
River with shells exploding all around him, but he never felt at ease with
such denomination, since he nurtured a deep respect for his trade colleagues,
among whom highlighted world class photojournalists like Henri Cartier-Bresson,
Alfred Eisenstaedt, Eugene Smith, David Seymour Chim, Werner Bischof, Ernst
Haas, Carl Mydans, David Douglas Duncan, Elliot Elisofon and many others.
5:45 a.m. It dawns in Thanh Né, Kien Xuong District, Province of Thai Binh (Vietnam). Robert Capa died when stepping on a mine in a large rice paddy located at three kilometers from this township on May 25, 1954.
5:45 a.m. It dawns in Thanh Né, Kien Xuong District, Province of Thai Binh (Vietnam). Robert Capa died when stepping on a mine in a large rice paddy located at three kilometers from this township on May 25, 1954.
Nevertheless,
his hugely agile and dynamic style of photographing, always striving after
being in the suitable place at the adequate moment, approaching as much as
possible to the persons he captured, often risking his life, his arduous steady
struggle to create the images from the most manifold angles feasible,
photographing the most defining instants, his deep love for the peoples of
every country in which he worked, his sincere empathy and compromise with the
human beings whom he immortalized with his cameras, usually depicting them in
dramatic contexts of misery, anguish, uncertainty, fear to death, utmost
necessity, etc, turned him into the embodiment of a new war photographer breed
working at great speed and with a very accurate timing handling the new miniature
format 35 mm Leica (between 1932 and mid May 1937) and Contax (between late May
1937 and May 1954) cameras, albeit his remarkable versatility enabled him to
also use the medium format 2 ¼ x 2 ¼ binocular Rolleiflex (since 1939).
Images like Leon
Trotsky During his Speech in Copenhaguen in 1932; the Harangue to the Republican Militiamen in the Finca of Villa Alicia by two anarchist chiefs at
midday of September 5, 1936, encouraging them to pluck up courage against the
impending battle against the professional Francoist troops; his coverage of the
Escape of the Refugees of Cerro Muriano across the north exit of the village
fleeing from the air raid on it; the iconic picture Death of a Loyalist
Militiaman; his impressive photographs taken near Fraga (Aragon Front) during
the Republican Offensive in Segre River in 1938 capturing the explosion of
shells of Francoist ordnance going off within very few meters from the spot
where he is located risking his life and in which you can almost perceive the
smell of powder; The Woman Running by Her Dog to Take Shelter from the Aerial
Sortie against Barcelona in January of 1939; the Escape of Catalonian Refugees
across the Barcelona-Taragona Road (including the dantesque images of the
stunned old woman walking around his carriage strafed by Italian fighters in
low flight which have killed all of his relatives, along with two mules and a
dog); the Refugees Going on Foot across the Barcelona- French Frontier Road;
his reportage in the Refugees Camps of Argelès-sur-Mer and Le Barcares in March
1939; the first wave attacking Omaha Beach on D-Day June 6, 1944 under the German
bullets, with plenty of American soldiers dying around him while he gets the
pictures jeopardizing his life at every moment; the Exceedingly Young American
Soldier Handling a Machine Gun in the Balcony of a House in Leipzig Who is Suddenly Killed by a Bullet in His Head Shot by a German Sniper on April 18, 1945; his
fabulous pictures of Pablo Picasso in his Paris Attelier in September 1944; his
images taken in Russia and Ukraine during his Trip with John Steinbeck in
August and September of 1947; his series in the Kibbutz of Negba (Israel) in
1949; the Little Girl Crying on the Left of the Image in the Temporary Camp
for Immigrants in Sha ´arha ´aliya, Haifa (Israel) in 1950; the Blind
Immigrants and Their Families near Gedera (Israel) in November-December 1950; his
touching images of Children in Tokyo, Osaka, Nara and Atami in April 1954; the
Disconsolate Young Vietnamese Woman Holding Her Little Child While Crying by
the Tomb of Her Husband in a Military Cemetery and many others (the list would
be huge) make up by themselves exceptionally valuable graphic documents bearing
witness to a lot of moments of seminal significance throughout XX Century and
above all what war is really about and his aftermaths for the human beings
suffering it.
LAST HOURS OF
LIFE OF CAPA IN VIETNAM AND PLACE OF HIS DEATH
May 24, 1954. Coming from Gia Lam airport in Hanoi, Capa has just arrived at a French airbase located in the south outskirts of Nam Dinh (45 miles in the southeast of North Vietnam capital) on board of a little Morane Saulnier MS-500 Criquet adapted aircraft with a French made 8 cylinder and 240 hp Argus As 10 engine together with John Mecklin (Time´s correspondent) and general René Cogny, commander of the French Forces in North Vietnam.
In spite of the short distance between both cities, it has been decided the transport by plane of both journalists and the high officer to avoid the risks that would involve a trip by land, because the Vietminh is very active in the areas of Thu´ o´ ng Tin, Cao Cuán, Phú Xuyén, Hu´ng Yên, Duy Tiên, Kim Báng, Lý Nhân, Hanh Liêm and Binh Luc, which occupy the space separating them from north to slightly southwest, and the French high command wants to guarantee as much as possible the security of the three men (Donald M. Wilson, correspondant of Life magazine in Indochina, who had accompanied Capa in Laos between May 10 and 16, 1954 during the coverage of the transfer of seriously wounded French soldiers by helicopters coming from Dien Bien Phu and who were subsequently taken to Hanoi by plane to be treated, had given his seat to John Mecklin, because the small airplane had only two places for journalists and besides, he had to type some pending chronicles for Life office in New York).
General René Cogny photographed by Robert Capa inside the Morane Saulnier MS-500 Criquet aircraft during the flight from Hanoi to Nam Dinh on Monday May 24, 1954, a few minutes before landing in the French Air Base of Nam Dinh. © Robert Capa / ICP New York
Therefore, the small aircraft lands in the French airbase of Nam Dinh, placed a few km in the south of Nam Dinh, and from there, Capa, Mecklin and general René Cogny go to Nam Dinh City by car,
In spite of the short distance between both cities, it has been decided the transport by plane of both journalists and the high officer to avoid the risks that would involve a trip by land, because the Vietminh is very active in the areas of Thu´ o´ ng Tin, Cao Cuán, Phú Xuyén, Hu´ng Yên, Duy Tiên, Kim Báng, Lý Nhân, Hanh Liêm and Binh Luc, which occupy the space separating them from north to slightly southwest, and the French high command wants to guarantee as much as possible the security of the three men (Donald M. Wilson, correspondant of Life magazine in Indochina, who had accompanied Capa in Laos between May 10 and 16, 1954 during the coverage of the transfer of seriously wounded French soldiers by helicopters coming from Dien Bien Phu and who were subsequently taken to Hanoi by plane to be treated, had given his seat to John Mecklin, because the small airplane had only two places for journalists and besides, he had to type some pending chronicles for Life office in New York).
General René Cogny photographed by Robert Capa inside the Morane Saulnier MS-500 Criquet aircraft during the flight from Hanoi to Nam Dinh on Monday May 24, 1954, a few minutes before landing in the French Air Base of Nam Dinh. © Robert Capa / ICP New York
Therefore, the small aircraft lands in the French airbase of Nam Dinh, placed a few km in the south of Nam Dinh, and from there, Capa, Mecklin and general René Cogny go to Nam Dinh City by car,
being received by Jean Lacapelle, commander of the French sector in that area, who suggests them to accompany him the following day during a mission of retreat of forces which will consist of evacuating and destroying the small French strongholds of Doaithan and Thanh Né, placed in far southeast of the Kien Xuong District of Thai Binh Province, near the boundary with Tien Han District.
A few hours later, Capa attends to an important meeting held inside the Nam Dinh French headquarters, getting pictures of general René Cogny and colonel Paul Vanuxen studying in some maps the current situation in the area. Unlike three years before when Jean de Lattre de Tassigny could held the city moving three armoured brigades and managing to curb the Viet Minh attack and its supply lines on June 6, 1953, preserving the control of the Red River Delta, now the French high officers knew that Nguyen Giap´s change of strategy towards widespread guerrilla warfare aiming at an attritional, protracted war, aided by plentiful manpower, and enhanced by proficient secret movements of troops to the ambushes positions avoiding the spotting from ground or air, subsequently performing a swift dispersal of troops during withdrawal, was paying off and the Vietminh forces dominated vast majority of rural areas in the Red River (Hông Sông) Delta.
Therefore, the French high command scheme would be to abandon the little garrisons of their own located in rural zones, impossible to defend against the guerrilla tactics and the deep knowledge of the ground by Vietminh, focusing their efforts on the important cities.
In the
afternoon, Capa and Mecklin go by car to the village of Phu Ly, around
40 km in the west of Nam Dinh, where they´re reported by French soldiers that
the Viet Minh is holding sway over the area and is carrying out frequent
sorties.
In the night,
after having returned to Nam Dinh, they lodge at a ramshackle boarding house
called Modern Hotel, where they meet Jim Lucas, correspondant of
Scripps-Howard, whom Capa had firstly met in Hanoi.
May 25, 1954
At 7:00 a.m,
Capa, Mecklin and Lucas mount on a jeep of the French army waiting for them
beside the door of the Modern Hotel and head for the northeast outskirts of Nam
Dinh to go to Thai Binh.
A few kilometers later, they wait by a stretch of the Red River (Sông Hông) for the French Force made up by 2,000 thousand men and 200 motor vehicles (including jeeps, trucks and tanks) to be ferried to the other side of this large fluvial way.
After crossing the river, the column of French troops advances in the direction of Thai Binh Province, penetrating into its area of Vu Thu, and approximately at 8:40 a.m,
they are attacked in the stretch of road between Bong Dien and Nghia Khe by Vietminh snipers who make long distance shots (between 500 and 800 meters) with Russian Mosin Nagant M44 caliber 7.62 x 54R caliber rifles and medium distance shots (between 350 and 400 meters) with Russian SKS caliber 7.62 x 39 mm carbines, bringing about some casualties among the drivers of the leading tracks.
The stress increases by bounds and leaps. The French and South Vietnamese soldiers of the column fear an encircling manoeuver by Viet Minh forces, who are camouflaged within the exceedingly lavish surrounding vegetation and clearly outnumber them. Besides, all of them are afraid of the possibility of being attacked with satchel mines, 57 mm Type 36 guns (Chinese copies of the American M18A1 recoiless rifle) or the much more effective SKZ 75 mm Sung Khong Giat recoiless rifles (designed by Tran Dai Nghia and manufactured in workshops with exceedingly low cost through the use of steel rails turned into bazooka components with tolerances below 0.5 mm) which could destroy the tanks of the French column.
A few kilometers later, they wait by a stretch of the Red River (Sông Hông) for the French Force made up by 2,000 thousand men and 200 motor vehicles (including jeeps, trucks and tanks) to be ferried to the other side of this large fluvial way.
After crossing the river, the column of French troops advances in the direction of Thai Binh Province, penetrating into its area of Vu Thu, and approximately at 8:40 a.m,
they are attacked in the stretch of road between Bong Dien and Nghia Khe by Vietminh snipers who make long distance shots (between 500 and 800 meters) with Russian Mosin Nagant M44 caliber 7.62 x 54R caliber rifles and medium distance shots (between 350 and 400 meters) with Russian SKS caliber 7.62 x 39 mm carbines, bringing about some casualties among the drivers of the leading tracks.
The stress increases by bounds and leaps. The French and South Vietnamese soldiers of the column fear an encircling manoeuver by Viet Minh forces, who are camouflaged within the exceedingly lavish surrounding vegetation and clearly outnumber them. Besides, all of them are afraid of the possibility of being attacked with satchel mines, 57 mm Type 36 guns (Chinese copies of the American M18A1 recoiless rifle) or the much more effective SKZ 75 mm Sung Khong Giat recoiless rifles (designed by Tran Dai Nghia and manufactured in workshops with exceedingly low cost through the use of steel rails turned into bazooka components with tolerances below 0.5 mm) which could destroy the tanks of the French column.
But general Nguyên Giáp, a master of logistics, managing with great ability the Viet Minh troops and a man featuring an
outstanding intelligence and wisdom, doesn´t want to massacre the French troops
performing a pitched battle, because of two main reasons:
a) The French
troops are well equipped with automatic and semiautomatic guns and have a
number of tanks. In addition, its officers belong to the French Legion, an
elite unit, so a massive combat of such nature would make inevitable a high
toll of casualties in his own ranks. As a matter of fact, a year before, the Viet Minh had launched an all-around battle against Nà Sân during the spring of 1953, and after very fierce combats and a high figure of killed soliders by both sides, the French material superiority prevailed in synergy with the hedgehog defense incepted by colonels Jean Gilles and Louis Bertil (Deputy Chief of Staff of General André Navarre, supreme comnander of the French Forces in Indochina.
b) Giáp knows that
during the first week of May 1954 France studied the possibility of launching a
massive aerial raid against the Viet Minh positions on the hills around Dien
Bien Phu with bombers and fighters (as a matter of fact, Viet Minh forces have been being attacked by American P-63 fighters - between 1949 and early 1951- , F8F Bearcats and F6F Hellcats fighters - between March 1951 and the present May 1954- and modified C-119 Flying Boxcars, all of them bought from USA, which have dropped bombs and napalm on them as a support to the French ground forces), and even Vulture Operation incepted to wholly disrupt the Vietminh forces around Dien Bien Phu included the possibility of dropping three atomic bombs against the Viet Minh forces
besieging Dien Bien Phu, to break the encirclement, though finally the good criterion of President Dwight W. Eisenhower prevailed and U.S didn´t support such initiative.
Besides, the U.S intelligence had spotted that Nguyen Giap cunning had foreseen that hypothesis, progressively advancing very much Viet Minh´s trenches towards the French strongholds in Dien Bien Phu, until being at only few meters distance from them, in such a way that from late April 1954 it would have been impossible for France to carry out any all out air raid separating the fortress itself from the blast range of both conventional or nuclear bombs which could be dropped
At the same time, he knows that the remarkable victory of Die Bien Phu meant a huge cost in lives for its men, specially on capturing Beatrice, Gabrielle and Isabelle strongpoints through wave attacks, defended by the professional French troops with great courage against forces outnumbering them.
Besides, the U.S intelligence had spotted that Nguyen Giap cunning had foreseen that hypothesis, progressively advancing very much Viet Minh´s trenches towards the French strongholds in Dien Bien Phu, until being at only few meters distance from them, in such a way that from late April 1954 it would have been impossible for France to carry out any all out air raid separating the fortress itself from the blast range of both conventional or nuclear bombs which could be dropped
At the same time, he knows that the remarkable victory of Die Bien Phu meant a huge cost in lives for its men, specially on capturing Beatrice, Gabrielle and Isabelle strongpoints through wave attacks, defended by the professional French troops with great courage against forces outnumbering them.
It wasn´t
finally done and Dien Bien Phu fell in Viet Minh hands on May 7, 1954, but the
highly experienced Vietnamese general knows that if he gives order to
annihilate the French column through a full scale onslaught, those having
created the Indochina War to earn money would have a further pretext to
increase the military escalade and even pondering again the possibility of
carpet bombing or a nuclear attack which would result in vary harmful
consequencies for the Vietnamese people, so he has chosen a guerrilla warfare
based on effective attacks in specific moments by means of snipers and mortars,
which progressively undermine the enemy´s morale, augmenting their fatigue,
making them feel that they´re being watched at every moment and that they could be obliterated them at any moment, with a clear message: Vietnam is our country,
this is a war that you can´t win, go away as soon as possible.
The French tanks
of the column open fire, but the huge camouflage ability with the ground of
Viet Minh guerrilla men and their great speed of movements makes their spotting
fairly difficult.
On the other
hand, temperature approaches 40º C, with thermal feeling of around 48 C,
because of the very high humidity levels of Vietnam. Therefore, heat is
scorching and the 2,000 soldiers and officers of the column sweat blood, in the
same way as Capa, Mecklin and Lucas.
After some
minutes of stressful wait, the column resumes its march, but once again, they
are attacked a few kilometers beyond,
in the stretch of road between Thuong Dien and La Dien, very near the river Song Mu Khe, when one of the trucks crosses on a mine and the explosion kills four men and leaves other six seriously wounded.
From here on, while the French column passes between Hoa Binh and Song An areas, the Viet Minh increases its pressure, attacking with 60 mm and 81 mm North Vietnamese made mortars and 82 mm Russian mortars and snipers equipped with Mosin Nagant M44 rifles and SKS carbines which beget some more casualties in its back.
Once more, the French tanks open fire, in the same way as many French soldiers shooting volleys with their Mat-49 submachine guns, Mas-36 and Mas-49 rifles and M1 Garand carbines, but with scarce effectiveness, since it´s virtually impossible to spot the Viet Minh soldiers, due to the very abundant vegetation surrounding them, so what they only get is to fire some adjacent villages.
in the stretch of road between Thuong Dien and La Dien, very near the river Song Mu Khe, when one of the trucks crosses on a mine and the explosion kills four men and leaves other six seriously wounded.
From here on, while the French column passes between Hoa Binh and Song An areas, the Viet Minh increases its pressure, attacking with 60 mm and 81 mm North Vietnamese made mortars and 82 mm Russian mortars and snipers equipped with Mosin Nagant M44 rifles and SKS carbines which beget some more casualties in its back.
Once more, the French tanks open fire, in the same way as many French soldiers shooting volleys with their Mat-49 submachine guns, Mas-36 and Mas-49 rifles and M1 Garand carbines, but with scarce effectiveness, since it´s virtually impossible to spot the Viet Minh soldiers, due to the very abundant vegetation surrounding them, so what they only get is to fire some adjacent villages.
Throughout all
the time, Capa has been getting pictures, moving quickly to and fro, and both
Mecklin and Lucas have been able to realize how his outstanding experience (a
veteran of five wars) makes him take risks only when he deems that a good
photograph can be made.
The column goes
on advancing, cross the zones of Vu Phúc and Vu Hoy and enter the District of
Kien Xuong (belonging to Thai Binh Province),
with the column following east direction between the area of Vu Qúy and Kien Giang river, until they arrive at Dongquithon fort, where they are briefed that there will be a delay of some hours, for the Vietminh has cut the road a few hundred meters beyond with some wide and deep trenches and has blown off the accesses to two bridges.
with the column following east direction between the area of Vu Qúy and Kien Giang river, until they arrive at Dongquithon fort, where they are briefed that there will be a delay of some hours, for the Vietminh has cut the road a few hundred meters beyond with some wide and deep trenches and has blown off the accesses to two bridges.
Capa runs
quickly to the front of the column and photographs the bulldozers and two
hundred prisoners of the Viet Minh while they repair the road.
The French
officer of Dongquithon fort invites Capa, Mecklin and Lucas to have breakfast
inside the small stronghold, but Capa decides to go on taking photographs for a
while.
Shortly after,
bathed in sweat and exhausted, Capa lies on the ground under the shade of a
truck, where Mecklin and Lucas find him at 14:00 h in the afternoon.
Some minutes
later, they hear that the most advanced vehicles of the column have already
arrived at Doaithan fort, so they mount on their jeep and dodging the rest of
vehicles and tanks of the column, reach the little and damaged fort of
Doaithan, surrounded by barbed wire and dense vegetation, at 14:25 h in the
afternoon, noticing that it is already being abandoned by its garrison, who is putting explosives in its merloned structure.
The column
renews its march and 200 meters beyond, a new ambush by Viet Minh kills some more soldiers within the French troops.
The heat is unbearable and fatigue has had an effect among the 2,000 men of the column for a long time.
The heat is unbearable and fatigue has had an effect among the 2,000 men of the column for a long time.
Capa asks
lieutenant colonel Jean Lacapelle if there have been any new developments and
his answer is laconic: ´ Viet Minh is everywhere ´ .
Capa is very
tired, but his love for his profession and his steady fight to get new and
better pictures, make him decide to jump on the front area of the jeep to take
further images from a different and more elevated angle.
The column
advances again eastbound, but once more is forced to stop by the combined
action of Viet Minh snipers using SKS carbines and Mosin Nagant M44 rifles and
Russian M1937, M1941 and M1943 82 mm mortars, and 60 mm and 81 mm North Vietnamese mortars handcraftedly made in workshops located in the mountains with tools transferred from the Caron factory at Haiphong under the supervision of engineer Tran Dai N´Ghia, top expert of Viet Minh about military technology, with background in both the École Polytechnique and the École Nationale Superiore de l ´Aeronautique of Paris, and whose gift enabled to produce a number of effective weapons with exceedingly low budgets and means, including a more than acceptable copy of the 81 mm American M1 mortar and its 3,11 kg M43A1 HE shells, and the optimized for portability Type 31 60 mm mortar ( a copy of the American M2 brainstormed by Tran Dai N´Ghia reducing costs to the utmost and with a range loss of only 300 hundred meters) and 60 mm Type 63 mortar (an updated version of the Type 31 in which the Vietnamese scientist attained to also reduce costs shortening the barrel length 11´64 cm with respect to the M2).
They are being attacked from different distances, because the Viet Minh snipers, located on both sides of the road, are shooting them from between 350 and 400 meters the ones equipped with SKS carbines and between 500 and 800 meters the ones using Mosin Nagant M44 rifles, while on their turn, the mortar crews of Viet Minh feature a huge experience and prowess in the handle of this gun, being able to determine the fire azimuth and its elevation adjustments in very few seconds, shooting their 60 mm, 81 mm and 82 mm shells with great accuracy and keeping to a minimum the time required to bring effective fires on the targets and changing quickly of position, managing to simultaneously protect mortars from enemy watching and direct fire.
They are being attacked from different distances, because the Viet Minh snipers, located on both sides of the road, are shooting them from between 350 and 400 meters the ones equipped with SKS carbines and between 500 and 800 meters the ones using Mosin Nagant M44 rifles, while on their turn, the mortar crews of Viet Minh feature a huge experience and prowess in the handle of this gun, being able to determine the fire azimuth and its elevation adjustments in very few seconds, shooting their 60 mm, 81 mm and 82 mm shells with great accuracy and keeping to a minimum the time required to bring effective fires on the targets and changing quickly of position, managing to simultaneously protect mortars from enemy watching and direct fire.
Capa perceives
clearly the huge danger and that Viet Minh is getting the upper hand shooting
from the nearby woods, camouflaged within the thick vegetation and without any
need to force a massive clash of forces, and they hold the initiative as to where and when to strike., keeping the French column under continuous observation from vantage points, it all fulfilled with great mobility and speed and selecting the most appropriate terrains for continuous ambushes, simultaneously managing to provide concealment to prevent detection from the ground or air, and grasping the element surprise and tactical initiative at every moment. Needless to say that the stamina of the French and South Vietnamese soldiers of the French column is waning because of these constant ambushes they´ve been suffering from some hours.
It isn´t the
first time that Bob watches a context of attack with fire of mortars, something
that already happened to him in December 1944 when he was embedded among the
tanks of the 37º battalion of the U.S 4th Armoured Division which
made its way through Bastogne to help the 101st Airborne Division
surrounded by German forces during the Battle of the Bulge and specially a year
before, on December 30, 1943, while he accompanied the vanguard elements of the
180th regiment of the U.S 45th Division during an
incursion on Venafro, a strategic Italian township in the Province of Isernia,
region of Molise (Italia), when suddenly they were attacked by German mortar
fire which killed an American soldier beside him, as a consequence of the
impact of three shrapnel fragments.
But even fully
aware that the risk is very high, Capa goes on getting pictures, moving around.
Mecklin and Lucas can see how Capa is jeopardizing his life for the nth time,
trying to get the best possible images.
He can
distinctly hear the whistling of the
high velocity 7,62 x 39 mm and 7,62 x 54R bullets shot by Viet Minh snipers featuring outstanding marksmanship,
who keep on making casualties, along with the explosions of the 60 mm, 81 mm and 82 mm shells
launched by the Russian and Vietnamese mortars of Viet Minh, which are provoking panic.
They´ve left Doaithan 1 km behind and they´re only 3 kilometers from Thanh Né, the final destiny of the French column.
They´ve left Doaithan 1 km behind and they´re only 3 kilometers from Thanh Né, the final destiny of the French column.
Stress is
maximum. Suddenly, Mecklin and Lucas see Bob coming back running to the
jeep and taking shelter behind one of his sides. He´s looking at the nearby
woods, trying to scan the trajectory of Vietminh rifle, carbine and mortar fire
that is being unleashed on the column.
The photographer
remains crouched behind the vehicle, endeavouring to protect himself from a
possible sniper bullet or from the shrapnel of mortar shells, the latter being the most dreaded, since the 60 mm rounds of Vietminh Type 31 and Type 63 mortars have a lethal range on exploding of around 22 meters, while their 81 mm and 82 mm mortars rounds have approximately a lethal range of around 35 meters on going off.
Adrenalin is
amplified many times over. A hail of rifle and carbine bullets along with mortar shells shot by Vietminh soldiers is falling on the French column in which Capa is embedded.
This has turned into a hell. The photographer knows that he must play it all out if he wants to get good pictures. Not in vain this has been his biotope for eighteen years since the Spanish Civil War, in which he had his baptism fire.
Robert Capa consistently attained to add a human side to his powerful war photographs throughout his entire professional career as a photojournalist, and his touching images still set standards in the scope of concerned photography. And everywhere he went, he managed to connect with people. His most important aim during his lifetime was to get the independence of photographers, who should own their own negatives, being able to sell their pictures for more than one magazine at a time, controlling their work and being respected.
As a matter of fact, his whole life has been a poker game, without a fixed abode, without a country, always roving and fighting for survival, since being only seventeen years old he became a political exile who had to flee Budapest in the morning of July 12, 1931 and emigrate to Berlin, which he would also have to subsequently abandon escaping from the Nazi anti-semitism.
This has turned into a hell. The photographer knows that he must play it all out if he wants to get good pictures. Not in vain this has been his biotope for eighteen years since the Spanish Civil War, in which he had his baptism fire.
Robert Capa consistently attained to add a human side to his powerful war photographs throughout his entire professional career as a photojournalist, and his touching images still set standards in the scope of concerned photography. And everywhere he went, he managed to connect with people. His most important aim during his lifetime was to get the independence of photographers, who should own their own negatives, being able to sell their pictures for more than one magazine at a time, controlling their work and being respected.
As a matter of fact, his whole life has been a poker game, without a fixed abode, without a country, always roving and fighting for survival, since being only seventeen years old he became a political exile who had to flee Budapest in the morning of July 12, 1931 and emigrate to Berlin, which he would also have to subsequently abandon escaping from the Nazi anti-semitism.
Capa decides to
leave the protection of the jeep and goes on getting pictures at full speed,
taking the risks that his experience enables him to calculate if the chance of
taking good photographs requires that way, but always with the presence of uncertainty
and hazard factor, who can bring about the death of any war photographer,
suddenly, in an unexpected way, at any moment.
The French
troops have been advancing for some minutes across a large rice field located
on the left of the road leading to Thanh Né. They walk slowly, very cautiously,
and some of them are wearing mine detectors. And in spite of the suffocating
heat, all the soldiers have their helmets on, because they are afraid of being
shot in the head by Viet Minh snipers.
Capa, who is
using two rangefinder cameras (a 24 x 36 mm format Contax IIa Black Dial made by Zeiss Ikon A.G Stuttgart with a coated Carl Zeiss Jena Sonnar 50 mm f/2 T lens and monochrome Kodak Super-XX film
and a Nippon Kogaku 24 x 34 mm format Nikon S with Nikkor-S.C 5 cm f/1.4 lens and
Kodachrome K-11 ISO 12 colour film) takes them some pictures from various
angles, mostly in black and white.
It´s 14:55 h in
the afternoon and Capa makes his two last photographs:
a) One in colour
with his Nikon S in which he captures seventeen soldiers of the French column
from behind (one of them, placed on the left of the image, is a wireless
specialist man, while the one located on the right nearest to the camera is
wearing a mine detector) and a tank that can be glimpsed in the background, slightly
on the right of the picture.
© Robert Capa / ICP New York.
On the right of the image can be seen the dike of a rivulet flowing on the right along with its slight slope giving to the road.
© Robert Capa / ICP New York.
On the right of the image can be seen the dike of a rivulet flowing on the right along with its slight slope giving to the road.
b) Another one in
black and white made with his Contax IIa, in which he captures nine men of the
French column, also from behind. This is the last picture made by Capa, a few
seconds before stepping on the mine, which was located on the slope visible on
the right just beyond the small dike, an area that almost 60 years later is
covered by trees and very dense vegetation.
© Robert Capa / ICP New York.
It can be seen that with respect to the previous picture in colour, Capa has quickly advanced diagonally towards the right, trying to get a picture from a different angle and in which both soldiers and the tank fill more the frame, in such a way that the tank which in the previous colour image appears slightly on the right of the middle area of the framing, now is visible on far left, while both the small dike and the slight slope beyond it appear much nearer.
© Robert Capa / ICP New York.
It can be seen that with respect to the previous picture in colour, Capa has quickly advanced diagonally towards the right, trying to get a picture from a different angle and in which both soldiers and the tank fill more the frame, in such a way that the tank which in the previous colour image appears slightly on the right of the middle area of the framing, now is visible on far left, while both the small dike and the slight slope beyond it appear much nearer.
Shortly after, Capa
decides to advance towards the slope, probably with the aim of getting more
pictures from a more elevated position, and on starting going it up, he steppes
on an antipersonal mine which had been installed at night by Viet Minh, who had detailed knowledge of the terrain.
The explosion
tears off his left leg and opens a huge wound in his chest.
Simultaneously,
the expansive wave throws his Nikon S some meters away (the photojournalist Sal
di Marco could see in early seventies some blood stains in this camera, when it was displayed at the Old Nikon House of New York, being currently
property of the Nikon Historical Society), while Capa,
unconscious and lying on his back on the floor, has his left hand still
grabbing his Contax IIa camera with which he has made his last picture, in
black and white.
Mecklin and Lucas arrive at the place of the explosion at 15:10 h in the afternoon. Capa has lost a lot of blood and is agonizing. Suddenly, colonel Lacapelle, who has heard the detonation, arrives. He sees Capa on the ground and quickly calls an ambulance which takes Bob to the first aid post located in Dong Qui Thon fort, 5 km behind, where a Vietnamese doctor certifies Capa´s death.
Mecklin and Lucas arrive at the place of the explosion at 15:10 h in the afternoon. Capa has lost a lot of blood and is agonizing. Suddenly, colonel Lacapelle, who has heard the detonation, arrives. He sees Capa on the ground and quickly calls an ambulance which takes Bob to the first aid post located in Dong Qui Thon fort, 5 km behind, where a Vietnamese doctor certifies Capa´s death.
A VERY LIVING
PHOTOGRAPHIC LEGACY
After Robert Capa´s
demise, the foundations of Magnum Agency, conceived by him and of which he was
his foremost driving force, crumbled, a fact that was even more apparent with
the almost simultaneous death of the genius Werner Bischof, who was Bob´s best
friend along with John G. Morris and David Seymour ´Chim´.
From this moment
on, there were a number of people who began working strenuously to continue the
work accomplished by Robert Capa and his defense of the rights of the photographers
together with the ownership of the original negatives: Henri Cartier-Bresson,
David Seymour ´Chim´, Cornell Capa, John G. Morris, Inge Bondi, Margot Shore,
Ernst Haas, Inge Morath, Elliott Erwitt, Eve Arnold, Dennis Stock, Burt Glinn
and many others.
At the same
time, it started to be created a team of people who would devote many years of
their lives to the classification and organization of the immense photographic
legacy of Robert Capa, made up by approximately 70,000 35 mm and 2 ¼ x 2 ¼ medium
format negatives, along with thousands of vintage copies and later ones:
Cornell Capa, his wife Edie Schwartz and Allan Brown began the task in mid
fifties, and Anna Winand (Kornél´s secretary) and James A. Fox (one of the most
important picture editors in history and editor-in-chief of Magnum Paris
between 1976 and 2000) arrived in mid sixties, until the Fund for Concerned Photography was founded in 1966, with Rossellina Bischof and Eileen Shneiderman (David Seymour Chim´s sister) also being instrumental in its creation.
They all made an
enormous and exceedingly important work, whose fruit would be the birth of the
International Center of Photography in New York, in whose inception Mischa
Bar-am likewise collaborated in a significant way.
ICP of New York. The steady efforts made by Cornell Capa, his wife Edie, Allan Brown, Anna Winand, Rossellina Bischof, Eileen Shneiderman, Mischa Bar-am, James A. Fox, Richard Whelan, Brian Wallis, Willis Hartshorne, Cynthia Young, Kristen Lubben, Fritz Block, master printer Teresa Engle Moreno, master printer Igor Bakht, Jeffrey A. Rosen, Caryl S. Englander, Mark Robbins, Gayle G. Greenhill, Frederick Sievert, Stephanie H. Shuman and others have turned this sancta sanctorum of top-notch photography into the most important flagship in its scope all over the world, and what began as an institution mainly devoted to preserve the photographic legacy of Robert Capa, David Seymour Chim and the genius Werner Bischof has turned into a venue of great and historical exhibitions of pictures made by a myriad of photographers from five continents, as well as being a top-of-the-line center for teaching of photography imparting a number of courses and seminars.
Amazingly, the elapse of years has made that Robert Capa´s photographic work and his prestige as a photographer increases more and more, along with his far-reaching significance in the History of Photojournalism, until reaching the present moment, a hundred years after his birth and almost sixty after his death.
ICP of New York. The steady efforts made by Cornell Capa, his wife Edie, Allan Brown, Anna Winand, Rossellina Bischof, Eileen Shneiderman, Mischa Bar-am, James A. Fox, Richard Whelan, Brian Wallis, Willis Hartshorne, Cynthia Young, Kristen Lubben, Fritz Block, master printer Teresa Engle Moreno, master printer Igor Bakht, Jeffrey A. Rosen, Caryl S. Englander, Mark Robbins, Gayle G. Greenhill, Frederick Sievert, Stephanie H. Shuman and others have turned this sancta sanctorum of top-notch photography into the most important flagship in its scope all over the world, and what began as an institution mainly devoted to preserve the photographic legacy of Robert Capa, David Seymour Chim and the genius Werner Bischof has turned into a venue of great and historical exhibitions of pictures made by a myriad of photographers from five continents, as well as being a top-of-the-line center for teaching of photography imparting a number of courses and seminars.
Amazingly, the elapse of years has made that Robert Capa´s photographic work and his prestige as a photographer increases more and more, along with his far-reaching significance in the History of Photojournalism, until reaching the present moment, a hundred years after his birth and almost sixty after his death.
As a matter of
fact, throughout the last five years, between 2009 and 2013, there have been unusual
levels of interest and expectation regarding the pictures made by Capa during
his 22 years of professional career, with a number of historical exhibitions
being held all over the world like This is War! Robert Capa at Work organized
by Cynthia Young (Assistant Curator of the ICP New York) with great effort and
painstaking care in New York, London, Barcelona, Milan, Madrid and Paris; Robert
Capa at the Ludwig Museum of Budapest between July 3 and October 11, 2009; Robert
Capa in China at the Leica Gallery of Vienna between February 13, 2013 and
April 13, 2013; Capa 1943-45 at the Galerie Daniel Blau, Paris Photo, between November 14 and 17 of 2013; Robert Capa Retrospective at Villa Marin Passariano del Friuli (Italy) between October 20, 2013 and January 19, 2014 and the Tokyo Metropolitan Museum of Photography between March and June 2014; Robert Capa 100 held in the Sejong Center for the Performing Arts of Seoul between August 2 and
October 28, 2013; Robert Capa in Italy 1943-1944 at the Museo di Roma Palazzo Braschi (between October 3, 1013 and January 6, 2014) which will be also displayed at the Museo Nazionale della Fotografia Fratelli Alinari in Florence between January 10 and March 30, 2014; Robert Capa 100 Years which is being held at present in the Hungarian National Museum of Budapest from September 18, 2013
and will last until January 12, 2014; Capa in Colour to be held at the ICP of New York between January 31 and March 4, 2014, and many others.
Another great
event that has fostered even more the comprehensive photographic legacy of
Robert Capa has been the finding of the famous Mexican Suitcase, including
4,500 original black and white negatives exposed by Capa, David Seymour ´Chim´
and Gerda Taro during the Spanish Civil War, along with some ones exposed by
Fred Stein in Paris and with which an itinerant worldwide exhibition has been held in New
York, Arlés, The National Museum of Art of Catalonia, the Museum of Bellas
Artes of Madrid, etc.
© Text and Indicated Photos: José Manuel Serrano Esparza
Article The Death of Robert Capa published in FV Photography Magazine Number 232
© Text and Indicated Photos: José Manuel Serrano Esparza
Article The Death of Robert Capa published in FV Photography Magazine Number 232